Recently, Logos 4 came out. One of the main comments was that the design was not intuitive. What exactly does intuitive mean? What must something be to be “intuitive”?
While I’ve been home for Thanksgiving, my mother has been playing around with my iPod touch. And then, last night, it hit me.
Intuitive: Adj. – def. Something my mother can pick up and do without instruction.
The iPod incident was remarkable. She was checking calendar dates, looking up things online, and typing on a virtual keypad. Amazing!
So, does Logos 4 meet this criterion for “intuitive”? Certainly not. Personally, I have used Logos 3 for over 2 years, and this upgrade has come as quite a surprise.
To be entirely fair, an important part of my Logos 3 setup was Phil Gons’ toolbar. http://philgons.com/resources/files/
Phil’s toolbar has been an incredible help in Logos. I only hope that the quick links and tweaks that he brought to the Logos 3 engine will either be included in 4, or that he will soon produce a similar product.
Logos 4 require time, patience, and a certain number of hours spent watching the instruction videos on the Logos website. http://www.logos.com/videos
Setup
I opted for downloading Logos 4, before I realized that it would take several hours. An estimated 5.4 GB of data had to be downloaded to my computer. Now, that was fine for my laptop, which I could take to a location with better internet speed. For my home desktop however, the download took nearly 2 days, 24 hours a day.
Other than the time factor, it was reasonably easy and required little input on my part.
Resource Intensive
Here’s my biggest problem with Logos 4 – It’s a huge resource hog. I decided to run some clock tests on my Netbook to see exactly how much more intensive Logos 4 is than version 3.
From clicking the Logos 4 Icon:
55 sec to the Login startup.
1:20 the Program window opened.
2:00 Book Loaded
From the time I clicked my Logos 3 Icon:
40 sec to home page
60 sec to book open
Technical Details: I am currently running Logos on an Acer Aspire One. Windows XP Home on an Intel Atom Processor, 1.6 Ghz, 1.5 MB RAM, 160 GB hdd. For this specific test, I was running Firefox, as well as various background programs including DropBox, Google Desktop, Zonealarm, and AVG Anti-Virus. Typically in class, I will also be running Bibleworks.
The fact of the matter is, I run these programs all the time. For Logos to be valuable to me in a class room, I often need it to load quickly. For example, something the prof says will spark something in my mind, and I will pull up one of my commentaries, or another reference book to check on something. If I’m waiting two minutes for the program to load, the professor is already onto another topic, and I’m behind in the discussion.
For more detailed research, I’m typically at home running a Desktop, Windows 7, P4 3.06 Ghz with HT, 1.5. GB RAM, 750 GB hdd. When I’m working on this computer however, the number of background programs jumps. While I have not done any timed tests on my desktop, I believe it is similar.
These are just startup times. The memory and processing power required to navigate through the program has also gone up. To be fair, they are including a great number of features that were previously unavailable. But they cannot entirely account for the slower speed.
Aesthetics
From a visual stand-point, Logos 4 is incredible. It is definitely the next step toward the newer standard for Program design. With Windows 7 out it’s a whole new ballgame, and I believe Logos 4 is a legitimate contender.
Features
I still cannot really comment on this. I haven’t had the time necessary to watch all of the videos available on the Logos Website. Hopefully over Christmas break, I’ll be able to soak up some of the available features. At this point however, it continues to look promising. So far, the ability to create your own handouts has potential, especially for local church ministry. The quick search feature will require some tweaking, but it seems to be a help that will prove useful once it gets ironed out.
Updates and Syncing
Two features not available in Logos 3 is the automatic updates and the Sync feature. For those like me who use Logos over multiple computers, it was always a hassle trying to remember what book you had open where, and almost impossible to carry over markups or highlighting. With Logos 4, that is all automated. For those of you familiar with Logos 3, you know that you had to manually start the update process, and while it was running you could not access the program. That has been changed to a background system in Logos 4. You will get a notification that Logos is downloading, and then it is reduced to a small icon in your system tray. No further input it needed until it is ready to be installed.
In Conclusion
I have no regrets upgrading to Logos 4. I do expect it to continue to improve, and the updates to continue to provide speedier program performance.
As for my part, is it just time to upgrade my computer? Perhaps. I realize my Netbook is vastly underrated for Logos 4, as is my desktop. But I look at recent technology, mainly Microsoft as a cue. Windows Vista OS failed to catch on because it was so hardware intensive that it could not be run on people’s existing computers. As they began upgrading to better, faster computers, things started improving. Eventually however, Windows 7 came out and is highly acclaimed. In fact, I even installed it on my old Windows XP desktop and it runs like a dream. I see Logos 4 slimming down at the same time people upgrade their hardware. In short, things can only get better from here.